PIRC warns of delays amid record death investigations
Scotland’s Police Investigations and Review Commissioner (PIRC) has warned that growing demand is delaying investigations into deaths involving the police, raising concerns about the impact on bereaved families and public confidence in police accountability.
The PIRC is currently managing 191 investigations, including 49 involving deaths. Commissioner Laura Paton said the organisation had experienced its highest ever number of simultaneous death investigations.
During 2025-26, PIRC opened 41 investigations into deaths, a 128 per cent increase on the 18 started in the previous year. Seven involved domestic abuse-related homicides and suicides.
The watchdog said its ability to complete investigations within target timescales had deteriorated as cases became more complex and its workload increased.
It completed 83 per cent of its highest-priority category A investigations within 90 days, down from 100 per cent in 2024-25. For category B and C investigations, 71 per cent were completed within 120 days, compared with 98 per cent the previous year.
Ms Paton said demand now exceeded the organisation’s available resources and was largely beyond its control.
“Without external intervention – such as a reduction in demand, additional funding or the delayed expansion of our statutory functions – a further deterioration in the timeliness of our investigations is inevitable,” she said.
PIRC assessed 745 referrals during the year and progressed 185 to full investigation. Of these, 175 (95 per cent) were instructed by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, leaving only 10 initiated at the commissioner’s discretion.
The increasing volume of investigations directed by prosecutors is restricting PIRC’s ability to undertake discretionary investigations, which can identify wider opportunities for learning and improvement in policing.
The watchdog is also preparing for an increase in applications from members of the public seeking reviews of police complaints as Police Scotland attempts to clear a significant backlog.
PIRC received 295 applications for complaint handling reviews during 2025-26, a 29 per cent increase on the previous year. It found that only 48 per cent of the complaints it reviewed had been handled reasonably by police.
The commissioner said delays in Police Scotland’s handling of complaints, alongside a growing number of people dissatisfied with the responses they receive, were a matter of considerable concern.
PIRC’s statutory responsibilities are also due to expand under the Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Act 2025, adding to pressure on its resources.
Ms Paton said the organisation was discussing the funding required to support the additional functions with the Scottish Government.
She warned that without action, the watchdog would struggle to provide the service expected by bereaved families, complainants and the wider public.


