Dorset PCC launches legal challenge over 'outdated' police funding formula

David Sidwick has instructed solicitors to begin formal legal proceedings unless ministers take urgent steps to reform the funding system ahead of future police funding settlements.

The PCC argues the formula has remained largely unchanged since 2013 and continues to rely on data and assumptions that are, in some cases, more than 25 years old. He says it fails to recognise the additional policing costs associated with Dorset’s large rural area and significant seasonal tourism.

According to the Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner, more than 25 million day and overnight visits are made to Dorset each year, creating additional demand during the summer months, while the county’s geography increases travel times, vehicle costs and operational pressures for officers.

Mr Sidwick said Dorset residents were paying disproportionately through council tax to make up the funding shortfall.

He said: “For years, Dorset Police and the people of Dorset have been short-changed by a funding formula that simply does not reflect the reality of policing our county.”

The legal correspondence sent to the Home Secretary argues that continued reliance on the existing formula is irrational and unlawful because it does not properly reflect current policing demand and therefore cannot promote the efficiency and effectiveness of policing, as required by law.

The PCC said he hoped to avoid court proceedings and instead reach a fair solution through discussions with ministers before the next police funding settlement.

A Home Office spokesperson said police funding would be considered as part of the Government’s forthcoming policing reform White Paper.

The spokesperson added that police funding had reached a record £18.4 billion this year, with Dorset Police receiving a 4.6 per cent cash increase compared with 2025/26.